Mechanical and electronic locks on a fence.

Mechanical Locks Vs Electronic Locks


The latest technology is introducing new ways of protecting your assets. Standard mechanical locks are rapidly being replaced by modern electrical locks & devices, but a question that many individuals have is: which device is more reliable and secure? We have compiled a list of the pros and cons for these two locking systems to help assist home and business owners decide which device best suits their security needs and offers optimal asset protection.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Mechanical and Electronic Lock Topics This Blog Includes:

    1. Mechanical Door Locks
    2. Electronic Locks: Digital & Smart Lock Systems
    3. Smart Locks
    4. Deadbolt Locks

Mechanical Door Locks

These types of locks operate 100% without electricity or batteries. They have been around for hundreds of years and are often a long-lasting solution for simple security needs. Mechanical locks, such as deadbolts, mortise locks, and cylindrical locks, have remained common due to their durability and straightforward design.

Cons include:

  • The technology has stagnated and has not kept up with modern security demands
  • Opening a high-security mechanical lock can sometimes be a slow process and may require you to start over repeatedly
  • Professional help is needed if there is any malfunctioning in the lock
  • Unauthorized key duplication can leave your business vulnerable without you even being aware of it
  • Mechanical locks cannot provide an audit of when the door lock has been accessed and by whom
  • Whenever keys are lost, stolen, or duplicated without permission, you incur the expense of changing every lock the key accesses

Pros include:

  • Reliable time-tested solutions since the 1800s
  • Hardware, such as deadbolt locks, tends to last a long time without the need for extensive repair work
  • Does not require electrical power
  • Often a weatherproof solution
  • Most employees are familiar with how to operate traditional door locks

Electronic Locks: Digital & Smart Lock Systems

Emerging security threats require the implementation of new technology to address those weaknesses. Additionally, standard mechanical locks can quickly cause inefficiency in business operations, are limited in function, and expensive to maintain properly. Electronic locks, on the other hand, offer flexibility, monitoring features, and easy integration with modern systems.

Cons include:

  • Need access to electricity via battery or another power source
  • If you lose power, you could temporarily lose the ability to open the lock
  • May require employee training to operate
  • May need to change the battery routinely
  • Many options and features associated with adding an electronic lock to your home or business often require professional assistance in choosing the best option

Pros include:

  • Added security with increased lock combinations compared to standard mechanical locks
  • Easily add or change combinations, such as on digital or keyless deadbolts
  • Easy to access and operate in the dark
  • Weather-resistant options are available
  • Add, block, or transfer users with specific access functions
  • Monitor access by time of day
  • Keep a record log of who accessed and when
  • Can often self-service the locks and make changes without paying for additional help
  • Can integrate additional hardware, such as intercoms, surveillance cameras, and key override mechanisms for added security
  • Many electronic locks offer compatibility with cam locks, improving security further

Smart Locks

Smart locks represent the latest advancement in the evolution of security technology. These electronic locks often feature keyless deadbolts and combination locks that allow homeowners and business owners to manage security from their smartphone or other connected devices. Smart locks can integrate with other security products to offer a seamless experience in managing access.

One of the biggest advantages of smart locks is their ability to allow remote access. You can lock and unlock your doors from anywhere in the world, giving you total control over your property, even when you're away. This eliminates the need for physical keys or manual locking, offering greater convenience and security.

Smart locks can also connect to home automation systems, allowing them to work in tandem with other security products like cameras or alarm systems. This seamless integration provides a holistic security solution, keeping you informed of all access activity while giving you peace of mind.


Deadbolt Locks

Among the many types of locks available, deadbolt locks are widely regarded as some of the most secure options for both residential and commercial properties. A deadbolt is a unique type of locking mechanism that differentiates itself from spring-operated door locks or latch systems because of its requirement of rotating the lock cylinder with a key. This makes deadbolts highly resistant to forced entry, as they cannot be opened by applying force or prying like some traditional locks. As a result, deadbolt locks are a popular choice for anyone looking to maximize the security of their home or business.

Deadbolt locks come in several varieties to suit different needs and applications. The most common types include mortise deadbolts and cylindrical deadbolts. Mortise deadbolts are installed inside the door, making them extremely difficult to tamper with, while cylindrical deadbolts are easier to install and are typically more affordable. Both options offer superior protection compared to standard latch or knob door locks and can be tailored to fit your security needs.

Tech preps a door for a deadbolt installation

In addition to mechanical deadbolt locks, there are also smart deadbolts that combine traditional deadbolt mechanisms with modern technology. These smart locks offer enhanced convenience and functionality by allowing you to control and monitor the lock remotely through a smartphone app. With a smart deadbolt, you can lock or unlock your door from anywhere, grant temporary access to visitors, or even receive alerts when someone tries to access your property. This combination of physical security and digital convenience makes smart deadbolt locks an excellent choice for those seeking both safety and ease of use.

Another critical consideration when choosing a deadbolt is its security rating. Deadbolt locks are rated by grade standards, which indicate their strength and durability. A grade 1 deadbolt is considered the highest level of security and is ideal for protecting entry points in both homes and businesses. Grade 1 deadbolts are built to withstand heavy use and provide maximum resistance to forced entry attempts. They offer peace of mind to property owners who prioritize safety.

When selecting a deadbolt lock, it’s important to match the lock to your specific security needs. For instance, for high-traffic areas or locations where you want a higher level of control, opting for a smart deadbolt might be the best choice, as it allows you to manage access remotely. On the other hand, if you’re looking for a more traditional but highly secure solution, a mechanical deadbolt would be ideal. Both types of deadbolt locks offer reliable protection against common break-in methods like forced entry or lock-picking, ensuring that your property remains secure.

For those considering the installation of deadbolt locks, it's important to recognize that deadbolts continue to be a cornerstone of secure locking solutions. Whether it's a smart deadbolt that offers smart home convenience or a robust mechanical deadbolt that stands the test of time, these locks provide an unbeatable combination of security and reliability. By choosing the right deadbolt for your door lock system, you are taking an essential step toward ensuring the long-term safety of your property.


What is the Next Step?

The commercial locksmiths at FlyLock Security Solutions and The Flying Locksmiths can install an intuitive electronic access control system that provides you with facility-wide management and control, offering an unmatched solution over the use of regular locks and keys. You can lock and unlock doors from anywhere and give your new employees immediate access only to the areas they need.

Whether it’s a basic lock and key or an old key card system, if you find yourself resonating with any of the reasons we’ve discussed to change or upgrade your locks, maybe it’s time to consider a new security solution. Your local, licensed, and insured FlyLock Security Solutions and Flying Locksmiths are here to help you make your best, educated decisions concerning your commercial security priorities. Contact us today!